01/02/2008

Clerical Dispute Erupts Over Child Sex Abuse Inquiry

A bitter dispute has emerged between the Archbishop of Dublin and his predecessor over how to deal with the Government's inquiry into allegations of child sex abuse in the Archdiocese of Dublin.

While Archbishop Diarmuid Martin has a policy of open access to church files, the former Archbishop, Cardinal Desmond Connell, has initiated High Court proceedings to prevent documents being handed over to the enquiry.

Lawyers for Cardinal Connell, who is a hospital in Rome following a fall, secured an interim High Court injunction - in place until a full hearing on the matter next Monday, preventing the investigators from examining certain documents claiming they are legally privileged.

In a statement issued last night, Dr Martin said he hoped "that the legal matters which have now arisen will be dealt with expeditiously for all concerned so that the commission can conclude its work".

He added: "Since its inception, the archdiocese has refrained from making any comment on the work of the commission. That policy remains unchanged, (but) the overarching aim of all must be that of attaining a more accurate understanding of the truth concerning sexual abuse of children by clergy."

The commission was set up by the Government in March 2006 to investigate allegations of child abuse between January 1st 1975 and May 1st 2004, against a representative sample of 46 priests.

Cardinal Connell was archbishop of Dublin from March 1988 until his resignation on April 26th, 2004, when Dr Martin became archbishop.

(VB)


Related Irish News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.

04 February 2008
Archdiocese To Co-operate With Inquiry
Bishop of Dublin Dr Eamonn Walsh has said the Archdiocese will co-operate fully with the Commission of Inquiry into clerical child sex abuse.
01 December 2009
Call To Expel Papal Nuncio Over Abuse Probe
The Papal Nuncio in Ireland has denied 'showing contempt' for the institutions of the State by refusing to respond to requests for information from the Commission of Investigation into the Catholic Archdiocese of Dublin.
11 February 2008
Cardinal Withdraws Blocking Bid
A leading Dublin cleric's bid to block the supply of files to the Commission investigating clerical sex abuse has been halted. A lawyer for the former Archbishop of Dublin, Cardinal Desmond O’Connor, withdrew a legal challenge against the disclosure of documents requested by the Commission of Investigation into Clerical Sex Abuse last December.
09 December 2009
Bishops Meet To Discuss Murphy Report
Ireland's Catholic bishops are meeting for the first time since the publication of the Murphy report into the Church's handling of clerical child abuse in the Dublin Archdiocese. The scheduled two-day winter conference in Maynooth is expected to focus on the damning report. Papal Nuncio, Archbishop Giuseppe Leanza, will be attending the meeting.
09 April 2009
Clerical Abuse Report Will 'Shock Us All'
The Catholic Archbishop of Dublin has said a forthcoming report into clerical sex abuse will "shock us all". The Most Rev Diarmuid Martin made the announcement during a homily delivered this morning at Mass in the Pro-Cathedral in Dublin. The report is due to be published this summer.