Call For 'Urgent Review' Of New Home Help Hours Score Card

Fianna Fáil has called for an urgent review of a new score chart introduced to assess and allocate home help hours.

Making the call, TD for Galway East Anne Rabbitte, said she wants to see a more flexible system, which understands the needs of individual cases rather than a "one size fits all" model.

Deputy Rabbitte described the newly introduced score chart as "extremely crude" and based on a number of "risk factors" rather than examining the overall needs of the person.

She continued: "All home help hours are allocated based on this scoring scheme. According to the weighting structure, someone who lives alone is given the highest score of 4, however a person who lives alone but receives visits from family members only receives a score of 2.

"The fact of the matter is that person still lives on their own, but because they may have family who live nearby they are not seen as having as much of a need for home help hours – which is a ludicrous conclusion.

"There are also serious staffing issues within the service – a number of cases have been brought to my attention whereby home help hours have been granted but there are no staff in place to provide them. This is a major problem for families who are dependent on these home help hours and it's deeply unfair.

"Home care packages are a central part of community health care. They allow older people, who may need assistance and support, to stay in their homes rather than having to be treated in hospital or in a nursing home.

"This is the preferred option for the majority of older people and their families and all attempts should be made to provide this service."

Deputy Rabbitte concluded: "The assessment score card is too rigid and needs to be made more flexible. Staffing levels and hours must also be increased. These issues need to be addressed as a matter of priority.

"Older people have a right to be cared for with respect and dignity in their own homes and every effort should be made to accommodate this. Minister Simon Harris and the HSE must find the necessary resources to ensure that home care packages can be provided to those who need them."


Related Irish News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.

17 January 2012
SIPTU Condemns Cutting Of Home Help
Worker's union SIPTU has slammed a proposed 4.5% reduction in home help hours proposed in the Health Service Executive (HSE) Service Plan. The union said the reduction, published on Monday, "flew in the face" of the Government’s stated commitment to primary care.
20 August 2015
'Urgent Need' For Professional Home Care Service
There is an "urgent need" to develop a professional home care service to Ireland's ageing population, Fine Gael has said. The party's Seanad spokesperson on Health, Colm Burke, said that the number of people aged over 65 is expected to double over the next 20 years, increasing from its present level of 585,000 to over one million.
29 October 2014
Charity Condemns Fair Deal Waiting Lists
Homeless charity ALONE has condemned a fifteen-week waiting list it says is facing Fair Deal Scheme applicants. The Fair Deal scheme aims to support people who need long-term financial home care.
10 April 2014
Long Term Care Needs Long Term Planning – Mac Sharry
Fianna Fáil Health spokesperson Marc Mac Sharry has told the Seanad that "long term care needs long term planning", at the launch of a debate on what has been described as an "imminent crisis in long stay nursing home care for the elderly".
30 January 2012
Regulate Home Care, Says Reform Commission
The Law Reform Commission has called for more regulation of the public and private professional home care service. The report also contained calls for a register of professional home carers to be set up. The report said home care provision by the State had been mirrored by the emergence of commercial home care providers.