Menu
19/09/2012
Irish Penal Reform Trust Call For Sentencing Reform
The situation where the Minister for Justice decides the duration of a prison sentence for those sentenced to a life term needs to be addressed, according to the Irish Penal Reform Trust.
The comments come after Malcom MacArthur, who was sentenced to life in prison for the murder of nurse Bridie Gargan in 1982, was given reviewable temporary release from prison on Monday after 30 years.
Executive Director of the Irish Penal Reform Trust Liam Herrick said that the Irish approach relating to this is out of step with best international practice.
He said the trend across other countries is to give a judicial body, such as a parole board or a court, the power to make decisions about when people are released.
Mr Herrick said that it was not possible to comment on or question the quality of the decision-making process by ministers.
However, he said that transferring the power to an independent body with the necessary expertise would be a way of ensuring the fairness of the process, especially in high-profile cases.
Mr Herrick said: "It removes any perception that either media controversy or political controversy might influence a minister if you simply remove it from the minister.
"That's what's happened in most other common law jurisdictions and in the civil law jurisdictions in Europe, generally. That power is given to a court, which is removed from the political system as well. I think that's much preferable."
(H)
The comments come after Malcom MacArthur, who was sentenced to life in prison for the murder of nurse Bridie Gargan in 1982, was given reviewable temporary release from prison on Monday after 30 years.
Executive Director of the Irish Penal Reform Trust Liam Herrick said that the Irish approach relating to this is out of step with best international practice.
He said the trend across other countries is to give a judicial body, such as a parole board or a court, the power to make decisions about when people are released.
Mr Herrick said that it was not possible to comment on or question the quality of the decision-making process by ministers.
However, he said that transferring the power to an independent body with the necessary expertise would be a way of ensuring the fairness of the process, especially in high-profile cases.
Mr Herrick said: "It removes any perception that either media controversy or political controversy might influence a minister if you simply remove it from the minister.
"That's what's happened in most other common law jurisdictions and in the civil law jurisdictions in Europe, generally. That power is given to a court, which is removed from the political system as well. I think that's much preferable."
(H)
Related Irish News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
05 January 2010
Undocumented Irish In US Emerge
A major effort is underway in the US to secure immigration reform and give undocumented Irish immigrants citizenship in the US. Senator Charles Schumer of New York is leading the effort in the senate to create new legislation to swing at least five key Republican senators behind the immigration reform proposals.
Undocumented Irish In US Emerge
A major effort is underway in the US to secure immigration reform and give undocumented Irish immigrants citizenship in the US. Senator Charles Schumer of New York is leading the effort in the senate to create new legislation to swing at least five key Republican senators behind the immigration reform proposals.
04 January 2012
Govt Criticised Over Juvenile Centre 'Failure'
The shelving of a plan to build a new juvenile detention centre has been called a 'failure' by a Penal Trust. Plans to build the new detention centre for teenage boys at Oberstown, Lusk, Co Dublin, were shelved due to a lack of funding, according to Minister for Justice, Equality and Defence, Alan Shatter this week.
Govt Criticised Over Juvenile Centre 'Failure'
The shelving of a plan to build a new juvenile detention centre has been called a 'failure' by a Penal Trust. Plans to build the new detention centre for teenage boys at Oberstown, Lusk, Co Dublin, were shelved due to a lack of funding, according to Minister for Justice, Equality and Defence, Alan Shatter this week.
08 July 2016
Fitzgerald Unveils Prison Officer Recruitment Campaign
Justice Minister Frances Fitzgerald has unveiled a new recruitment campaign which aims to recruit up to 360 prison officers over the next three years.
Fitzgerald Unveils Prison Officer Recruitment Campaign
Justice Minister Frances Fitzgerald has unveiled a new recruitment campaign which aims to recruit up to 360 prison officers over the next three years.
16 May 2008
'Large Irish Presence' At Cannes
The focal point for the Irish film industry at the Cannes Film Festival, the Irish Pavilion, has opened again for business this week, with over 200 of the leading lights of the Irish film industry flying out to the festival to promote and sell new Irish cinema.
'Large Irish Presence' At Cannes
The focal point for the Irish film industry at the Cannes Film Festival, the Irish Pavilion, has opened again for business this week, with over 200 of the leading lights of the Irish film industry flying out to the festival to promote and sell new Irish cinema.
13 March 2024
First And Deputy First Minister To Celebrate St Patrick's Day In US
The First and Deputy First Minister will travel to the United States this week for a series of St Patrick's Day engagements in Washington DC. The visit will focus on showcasing the local economy and develop key relationships and networks across the U.S. Ministers will attend the NI Bureau Breakfast, Ireland Funds Gala, a meeting with the U.S.
First And Deputy First Minister To Celebrate St Patrick's Day In US
The First and Deputy First Minister will travel to the United States this week for a series of St Patrick's Day engagements in Washington DC. The visit will focus on showcasing the local economy and develop key relationships and networks across the U.S. Ministers will attend the NI Bureau Breakfast, Ireland Funds Gala, a meeting with the U.S.
-
Ireland WeatherThis Evening and Tonight:Dry in the southeast at first otherwise widespread light rain or drizzle for most. It will turn mostly dry towards dawn, although a few patches of light rain or drizzle continuing, mainly in the southwest. Minimum temperature 5 °C.
